copy and paste this google map to your website or blog!
Press copy button and paste into your blog or website.
(Please switch to 'HTML' mode when posting into your blog. Examples: WordPress Example, Blogger Example)
What is the purpose of the “Comments only to the editors” section in . . . Your report to the authors and your comments to the editor serve two different purposes and should address two different audiences Your report to the authors should help them improve the paper When writing these reports, regardless of my opinions of the paper, I maintain a positive tone
Confidential Comments To Editor | PDF - Scribd The document provides 4 examples of confidential comments an editor may provide to authors The first manuscript was timely but poorly written with an inadequate literature review The second was clearly written by multiple authors with opinions stated as facts without citations
Peer Review, Confidential Comments to the Editor, and the Golden Rule Two boxes are available in which to make online comments, “Reviewer Comments to Author,” and “Reviewer Confidential Comments to Editor ” Comments to authors are shared with the authors; comments to the editor are not
checklist for Confidential Comments to the Editor Confidential comments to the editor will not be shared with the authors and might include: A definite recommendation regarding publication; An assessment of how much any suggested additional experiments would improve the manuscript, and of how difficult they would be to complete within a reasonable timeframe (1-2 months);
Writing Constructive Reviewer Comments - EHP Publishing When submitting your review, you will be asked to: recommend accept, revise, or reject complete a brief questionnaire provide confidential comments to the editor provide comments to the author Rate the manuscript on its significance, relevance, and clarity
3. 2 The comments to editors and decision recommendations Continuing your learning on how to write a helpful peer review report, this section discusses the confidential comments you can make to the editor and explains the decision recommendations you can make
Guidelines for reviewers - American Psychological Association (APA) Your comments to the editor are confidential and will be read only by the editors; they will not be shared with the authors, at least not verbatim In some cases, an editor may paraphrase or refer to your comments when communicating with the authors
Guidance from our Editors - BMJ Author Hub In your confidential comments to the Editor, be as candid as you can regarding the work, highlighting any irregularities, concerns etc It is also helpful to provide what you think is the minimum requirement for accepting a revised manuscript, even if you have suggested the authors do much more
Writing your report | Nature Reviews Microbiology Confidential comments to editors Your comments to the authors should contain all feedback pertaining to the scientific evaluation of the manuscript, as detailed above
Guidelines for Ethical Behavior in Publishing Confidentiality: The editor-in-chief, department editor, associate editor, and any editorial staff will not disclose any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the authors, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers, and the publisher